meeting ground rules

A common misunderstanding about defeated motions

By Ann Macfarlane / July 10, 2020 / Comments Off on A common misunderstanding about defeated motions
A red rectangular stamp with the word "FALSE" in bold, distressed capital letters reflects a defeated motion.

  The History City News in Missouri published an account of a commission meeting that got Robert’s Rules of Order wrong: Under Roberts Rules of Order, Commissioner Henry Dean could not offer a motion during the County Commission meeting yesterday to mandate the wearing of face masks in the county since it failed last week.…

Read More

No debate at all—legitimate, but unwise

By Ann Macfarlane / July 6, 2020 / Comments Off on No debate at all—legitimate, but unwise
3D text displaying the word "NO" in bold, blue letters against a plain white background—there's no debate at all that its message is clear.

  A citizen rang me up in some concern about the way his city council had processed a big motion the night before. The land-use proposal was introduced and seconded, a member was recognized to debate, and that member immediately said, “I call the question.” Five of the seven members on the council voted in…

Read More

Can you kick a member out of a membership meeting?

By Ann Macfarlane / May 29, 2020 / Comments Off on Can you kick a member out of a membership meeting?
A green road sign with the word "Goodbye" written in white letters against a cloudy sky background echoes the sentiment of kicking a member out.

Nonprofit membership organizations sometimes are plagued with members who create difficulties at meetings. What can you do about that? Can you kick a member out of a membership meeting? And if so, how? Our article, Dealing with difficult members, lays the groundwork for this post. Download PDF Rights and responsibilities Attending membership meetings is one…

Read More

Our worst selves

By Ann Macfarlane / May 15, 2020 /
Two elephants face each other with their tusks touching, appearing to engage in a playful or competitive interaction on a dirt path surrounded by greenery. In this wild yet serene moment, they remind us of our worst selves and the primal instincts within.

  When I served on the board of the American Translators Association, a fellow board member drove me crazy. His blithe assumption of superiority and his ego were insufferable. Of course, it is a truism of psychology that a strong emotional reaction like that is linked to unresolved inner issues. When I looked at the…

Read More

Tips for government bodies meeting remotely

By Ann Macfarlane / March 30, 2020 /
A person participates in a remote video conference call on a laptop with four other individuals, holding a document displaying a colorful pie chart, during an important government bodies meeting.

  The big moment is here. You’ve done your due diligence by: reviewing any emergency declarations affecting local government meetings in your state, studying how your body can proceed in light of the Coronavirus/COVID-19 emergency, planning with your staff, consulting your attorney, and choosing an online platform. You’re all set to launch your first totally…

Read More

Essential tips for effective online meetings

By Ann Macfarlane / March 25, 2020 / Comments Off on Essential tips for effective online meetings
A woman in a business suit participates in an online meeting with three colleagues on separate monitors.

  Moving your meeting online presents special challenges. Here are our best tips for success. Make sure you can meet this way. Refer to state law and your bylaws to make sure you can meet by telephone or videoconference. Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised, 11th edition, discusses this issue on pp. 97-99. According to…

Read More

Reconsider, Rescind, or Amend previous decision

By Ann Macfarlane / March 11, 2020 / Comments Off on Reconsider, Rescind, or Amend previous decision
A spiral notebook with "Let's Rethink" written in black and red text, placed on a wooden surface. A red marker, a capped red pen, and a pencil are beside the notebook, inviting you to reconsider your ideas.

Updated October 3, 2023 Some years ago, I had a dramatic exposure to the motion “to Reconsider.” At a 2-day meeting of our professional society board, one member (I’ll call him “Alex”) proposed that our society spend $4000 on radio spots in Washington, DC. He felt that we needed to develop a public relations strategy,…

Read More

“Stand at ease” creates breathing space in meetings

By Ann Macfarlane / March 4, 2020 / Comments Off on “Stand at ease” creates breathing space in meetings
A beach scene with a wooden lounge chair standing at ease under a white umbrella on the sandy shore, with a clear blue sky and the calm sea in the background.

  Have you ever had one of those desperate moments in a meeting where you just don’t know what to do? I certainly have! There is a great tool to use at such a time. The chair can direct the members to “stand at ease.” This means that business of the meeting is on pause…

Read More

Run better work meetings using Robert’s Rules

By Ann Macfarlane / October 16, 2019 /
A group of people sitting around a large table in a conference room, working on laptops and engaged in discussions typical of work meetings. A whiteboard with writing is visible in the background.

A colleague asked for our best tips on leading committee meetings at work using Robert’s Rules. In general, Robert’s Rules don’t apply at work The first and obvious point is that work is not a venue where Robert’s Rules and parliamentary procedure apply. That system of meeting management is designed for assemblies—groups—where all members have…

Read More

Do Robert’s Rules drive you crazy?

By Ann Macfarlane / October 10, 2019 / Comments Off on Do Robert’s Rules drive you crazy?
An elderly woman wearing a pink visor and glasses is sitting inside a boat on dry land, next to a fence and trees, calmly reminiscent of Robert's Rules. The boat boasts the registration number CF 0124 SX and features a red Lake County sticker.

When I posted this question, Betsy Cawn of Lake County, California wrote a short and pungent response. Much appreciated, Betsy! Thanks to you, Ann, Robert’s Rules DO NOT drive me crazy — but unlearned colleagues who refuse to even discuss the abbreviated set of “simple guidelines” you provide certainly DO. Somewhere between the extreme formality…

Read More