Don’t vote to accept, adopt, approve or receive reports
Updated November 20, 2022
Boards and councils often fail to process reports correctly. When an officer or a committee submits a written report, the board usually should NOT vote to accept, adopt, approve, or receive it. Instead, the report is noted as received for filing. No action is necessary. The minutes simply state:
Last month’s expense report was received for filing.
The clerk or secretary keeps the report in the organizational records. Ordinarily it is not a part of the minutes. However, when a committee report is of great importance or should be recorded to show the legislative history of a measure, the board can order it “to be entered in the minutes,” in which case the secretary copies it in full or attaches it to the minutes.
Why not vote to accept reports?
The reason for this guideline is that when a board votes to accept, adopt, or approve a report, it endorses its contents in their entirety. This led to a big kerfuffle a few years ago in the City of Bar Harbor, Maine. A group of citizens spent months preparing a substantial report on ways to manage the impact of the tourism industry. The city council voted to approve the report, but then did not implement its suggestions. Citizens were understandably upset.
Don’t vote to accept the treasurer’s report
This principle applies to financial reports as well. When your board receives the monthly treasurer’s report, you should not vote to approve it. A vote to approve indicates that the board stands by the report, whereas in fact, there is no foundation on which to stand. You have no way of knowing whether it is correct or not.
DO vote to approve the auditor’s report
At the end of the fiscal year, the treasurer will prepare an end-of-year report, which should be audited. If you are a large organization, this will be done by a certified public accountant. If you are smaller in size and budget, two members can be appointed as an audit committee. The auditors will review the numbers. If they find no irregularities, they will submit it to the board with the endorsement “Audited and found correct.” The board will then vote to adopt the report. Approval by the board relieves the treasurer of responsibility for the period covered by the report, except in case of fraud.
DO vote to approve bills to be paid
Sometimes boards receive a list of warrants or bills to be paid. This is different from an informational financial report. You are authorizing action in accord with your assigned responsibility, and so you will naturally vote to approve this list.
DO vote to approve the Planning Commission report if you wish to accept its recommendations
If the Planning Commission or another citizen advisory committee has presented a report, and the city council wishes to accept it, by all means vote to adopt or approve it. This means that you have decided to do whatever was recommended—you have adopted it as the council’s action.
DO vote on motions contained in a report once they have been made
If a report contains recommendations for action, it is customary for the chair of the committee, after presenting the report, to move adoption of the motions it contains. No second is needed for such a motion, since in preparing the committee report, more than one person voted to approve the recommendations. The board will process the motions in the usual manner and may, of course, vote to amend the committee’s suggestions.
YOU MAY INCLUDE brief summaries of oral staff reports
Many bodies, especially local governments, include brief summaries of oral staff reports in their minutes. This is fine as long as it does not become too great a burden on the clerk or secretary. You might want to request the staff members themselves to provide the summary for the minutes.
Read more about reports in Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised, 12th edition. Here are some relevant sections:
- 47:35 Records of the Secretary
- 48 Minutes and Reports of Officers
- 51 Reports of Boards and Committees
Wow, did NOT know that. We’ve voted to accept a Treasurer’s Report and the Planning Commission’s Recommendation at council meetings, and we’ve voted to accept/receive the treasurer’s report at the Lions Club.
I don’t know if I’ll get them to change, but this is a good thing to know. Our attorney should have.
Thank you Julia. It is fine to accept a planning commission report with action recommendation if you plan to adopt it. I will clarify that in the body of the post. Great to hear from you.